Scaling Challenge

I’ve been playing a lot of Legendary:Villains lately and have been having a good time with it. I really enjoy the feeling of progression in games, starting with something relatively weak that works poorly and building up towards having something epic. I definitely got a buzz out of dealing Graham’s number damage (though the legality of the move hinges on whether discarding a card, shuffling it back into your deck and reclaiming it and discarding it again counts as “discarding two cards” or “discarding the same card twice”) but that was met with a slight disappointment that there was no target that justified that quantity of firepower.


Continue reading

My games are not for me

In some of the discussions of the use of miniatures of Wizard’s Academy I mentioned that I don’t particularly value miniatures as part of a game, which seemed to cause a great deal of shock and alarm in some individuals. This is going to be a difficult article for such people to read because I’d like to talk about an aspect of game design that’s rarely discussed, but that I’m sure everyone does: I make decisions that mean that I find my games less enjoyable so often that I couldn’t begin to estimate the total number of such decisions.

cutting-tree Continue reading

Room for Innovation

So there’s this conversation I keep seeing on game design forums:
Enthusiastic_Newbie “I’ve come up with a great new mechanic for my game!”
Old_Hand “There are no such thing as new mechanics, what is it?”
EN “(Description)”
OH “That’s been done before in (Game) (Game) and (Game). Perhaps once in a generation someone comes up with a new mechanic, the odds that it’s you are millions to one.”
EN “Oh”
OH “Don’t try to invent new mechanics.”
Unenthusiastic_Newbie “Oh, okay. Thanks I guess.”


Continue reading


I was reading a thread on BGG the other week talking about designing a MOBA (multiplayer online battle arena) board game. It’s an interesting challenge for a number of reasons, the thread is interested in looking at one particular approach towards it so rather than derail there I thought that I’d tackle it here. I’ll try to stay away from genre specific terminology to keep the discussion open to everyone.

dota Continue reading